Recommends the following Real Estate Agents.

For Fire Island Pines Real Estate as well as Cherry Grove Real Estate visit us here.

If you are serious about Fire Island Real Estate we strongly suggest that you speak with one of our recommended specialists.

Fire Island Specialist

Tanya A. Fuchs
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Fire Island Specialist
Douglas Elliman
(631) 478-8546

Fire Island Real Estate Agencies

Evelyn Danko, Licensed Real Estate Broker and owner has been doing business in the Grove for 24 years. In the business of sales and/or rentals she services the Cherry Grove, Fire Island area.
P.O. Box 4062
Cherry Grove, N.Y. 11782

Barrier Beach Properties
For Fire Island rentals and sales, contact Linda Cahill of Barrier Beach Properties, the Saltaire real estate professionals. Barrier Beach Properties offers the largest selection of Saltaire homes for sale and for rent.
202 Atlantic Walk
Saltaire, NY 11706
212-861-2029 (off-season)

Cherveny Real Estate
Fire Island Real Estate services in Atlantique, Lonelyville, Robbins Rest and other Western Fire Island communities.
P.O. Box 341
Ocean Beach Fire Island, NY 11770

d.katen fire island properties, ltd.

Voted number one in professional real estate service in The Pines. The owner/broker, Doreen Katen, is a year round resident and native of the island. Serving Fire Island Pines, Cherry Grove, and Water Island.
P.O. Box 5344
Fire Island Pines, NY 11782

Dana Wallace Real Estate
A family owned and operated business with over 30 years experience serving Fire Island. Located in the heart of Ocean Beach just steps from the ferry specialize in sales and rentals in Ocean Beach, Seaview, Ocean Bay Park, Corneille Estates, Summer Club and Robbins Rest.
481 Bayberry Walk
Ocean Beach N.Y. 11770

Fire Island Homes LLC.

With over 50 years combined real estate experience. Specializing in the communities of Ocean Beach, Seaview, Ocean Bay Park, Corneille Estates, and Summer Club.
Bayberry Walk
P.O. Box 444
Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Fire Island Living Real Estate
Fire Island Living Real Estate specializes in real estate sales and rentals in Saltaire, Fair Harbor, Kismet, Dunewood and Lonelyville.
P.O. Box 5421
Bay Shore, NY 11706

Larson Realty
RoseAnn and Ken Larson are the husband and wife team behind Larson Realty and have been year round residents living in Saltaire since 1992, and Ken on Fire Island for over four decades.
206 Broadway in Saltaire
(631) 583-9100

Pines Harbor Realty
Fire Island Real Estate Fire Island Pines
If your looking to rent or buy a property on Fire Island Pines or Water Island, Pines Harbor Realty can take care of all your real estate and rental needs.
P.O. Box 219
Sayville, NY 11782

Douglas Elliman Real Estate
CJ Mingolelli
Skilled in meeting special requests for sellers and buyers – whether you’re ready to market your home, or are looking for your next home, whether it’s the city life, the Island life, or both – whether you’re looking a quiet private setting, or the activity-filled days of a home close to the happenings – CJ Mingolelli of Prudential Douglas Elliman Real Estate can help.
301 West Main Street,
Sayville, NY 11782

Fire Island Summer Vacation Rentals

Did you know that Fire Island offers some amazing options for vacation rentals? These stunning vacation accommodations allow you to enjoy the beach and attractions of Fire Island without sacrificing luxury. Many of the Fire Island vacation rental locations offer some amazing features, such a private beach, and a wraparound deck, so you can relax in luxury and enjoy the natural beauty that Fire Island beaches have to offer.

Looking for amenities? Many of the luxury vacation rentals on Fire Island offer amenities such as canoes, tennis courts, pool tables, and fitness centers, so you can enjoy your free time to the fullest.

Want to spend your whole summer on Fire Island? Many of the vacation rentals available can be rented by the month or for the entire summer! Keep in mind that prices vary from month to month, depending on the housing demand and season. If you’re looking to save a little cash, plan your summer vacation in June or September.

If you are looking to party in luxury, check with your potential rental locations about their policy on renting to singles or a group, as some of the rental locations will only rent to families.

Looking for a Vacation Rental on Fire Island for next summer? Keep in mind that many of these spots are rented quickly, so be sure to book your vacation rental early!

Feeling a little overwhelmed by the process of finding a vacation rental in time? Check out our Fire Island Rentals page for a list of the best real estate agents on Fire Island to keep your vacation planning stress-free.